Last week, my babysitter arrived at the house to watch the IT kids. I asked her if her new purple ski jacket had arrived. I was greeted with a huge “HUH?” and “How did you know I bought a purple ski jacket?”
Oh, she didn’t just buy a purple ski jacket, she bought two other iteams as well. From Overstock.com. And how did I know? She told me. Sorta. It was in her Facebook news feed.
We had no idea how this happened until I saw Charlene Li’s post on her most excellent marketing blog. Babysitter said repeatedly she never linked Overstock to her Facebook account, nor did she ever click anything that said they would communicate.
I’ve bought movie tickets from Fandango where they asked if I wanted to share info with Facebook and I’ve said no. I cannot imagine I would want anyone on Facebook to know what I am purchasing (giving silent thanks that Nordstrom does not do this for I don’t want everyone to know the deals of my last La Perla purchase). What makes it worse is babysitter did not make this choice, and yet I knew everything she had bought on that shopping trip. Charlene’s story is funnier (she and her husband actually bought the same thing) but no more less reassuring.
I’m not sure why Overstock is choosing to do this, but I do know that as a consumer I would prefer to have the option of whether or not to share this info with others. The last thing Mr. IT needs is a detailing of any of my shopping expeditions.
Posted by Stevie Wilson on November 26, 2007 at 9:19 pm
I am so glad to read this blog. I posted about Jonathan Trenn’s first blog about Facebook Beacon and I can’t imagine what would happen if someone knew what personal items I bought from drugstore.com or that I bought something for a gfit and it was all over Facebook– particularly something that was a gag gift for a bride..
Facebook– what is your motivation other than making money? This isn’t smart!!
Stevie
Posted by Facebook Beacon Revamp: Will It Go Far Enough? - GigaOM on November 29, 2007 at 10:04 am
[...] and Wiley marketing director Ellen Gerstein discovered how subtle those notices were when she congratulated her babysitter on buying a purple ski jacket. Her babysitter had no idea that her Overstock.com purchases were [...]
Posted by Unit Structures – Facebook rethinks Beacon on August 22, 2008 at 2:24 pm
[...] users to approve a story before it is sent to the Newsfeed. This does address some of the concerns regarding information leaks through [...]
Posted by fenita Arzate on November 19, 2008 at 3:10 am
Interesting Read! Very detailed blog,thanks for sharing